Do Auditors and Investors Agree on What Matters in ESG Reporting?
Summary
This study examines whether auditors and financial statement users (such as investors) evaluate the importance (materiality) of environmental, social, and governance (ESG) disclosures differently than traditional financial disclosures. As ESG assurance becomes more common and regulators increasingly require independent assurance over ESG reporting, understanding these differences is essential. The researchers conducted an experiment involving 108 experienced auditors (86% CPAs with an average of 7.2 years of experience) and 190 financial statement users who evaluated eight disclosures that varied by whether they were ESG or financial, qualitative or quantitative, and positive or negative.