Back to Library
Would Employees Rather Be Evaluated by AI or a Human Manager?

Would Employees Rather Be Evaluated by AI or a Human Manager?

Summary

Firm Practice Management Management Accounting Technology

This study examines how using artificial intelligence (AI) instead of a traditional White male manager to evaluate employee performance affects recruitment, employee effort, and retention across different demographic groups. The researchers conducted two controlled experiments involving more than 1,200 participants. One experiment examined whether prospective employees would accept a job offer based on who conducted performance evaluations, while the second explored how current employees responded to negative performance feedback. The study is timely because approximately 40% of international HR departments already use AI-driven tools for employment decisions.